Press release

Market share no longer guarantees a place in AI shopping answers, the new retail battleground—Bain & Company

Market share no longer guarantees a place in AI shopping answers, the new retail battleground—Bain & Company

  • listopada 20, 2026
  • min read

Press release

Market share no longer guarantees a place in AI shopping answers, the new retail battleground—Bain & Company
  • Bain analyzed more than 4,400 shopping prompts and 300,000 unique runs across top large language models (LLMs), powered by Profound data, to determine which retailers show up in AI answers
  • Retail category specialists often over-index in AI answers relative to their market share
  • One-third of US and European consumers now use AI assistants in their shopping journey
  • Consumers still trust retailer-built AI agents most despite a rise in third-party agent adoption

NEW YORK—November 20, 2026—AI is upending the traditional shopping funnel as more consumers look to agents for purchase recommendations. That means retailers absent from AI answers will cede traffic, awareness, and profits, finds Bain in a new report: AI Is the New Search. Here’s How Retailers Win the Answer.

Leading retailers will compete for traffic on three new but rapidly growing fronts, says Bain: third-party (3P) assistants, first-party (1P) assistants, and customers’ personal AI agents. And while 3P visibility is table-stakes, market share alone no longer guarantees retailers will show up in AI search answers.

Bain analyzed more than 4,400 shopping prompts across four retail verticals, testing over 300,000 unique runs across the most used large language models (LLMs), powered by Profound data, to understand what earns a retailer a place in AI answers. For many retail verticals, category specialists often over-index in AI answers relative to their market share versus general retailers.

“AI visibility shifts constantly, so it needs the same ongoing attention as pricing or delivery,” said Aaron Cheris, global head of Bain & Company’s Retail practice. “AI assistants are rewarding the retailers that are clearest about who they serve and what they do best, because shoppers ask specific questions and specific answers win. The retailers that spell out their value proposition clearly for the bots, organize around the occasions shoppers care about, and build their own assistant will be best placed to win this holiday season and beyond.”

Agents may not be purchasing yet, but they influence consumer decision-making

Nearly 33% of US consumers and 36% of European consumers now say they use AI assistants for some part of the shopping journey, up from 19% and 8%, respectively, in 2025, per Bain’s Consumer Lab global survey.

While AI assistant referral traffic still accounts for less than 1% of retailers' web traffic overall, click-through data and final purchases undercount agent influence. Many shoppers use AI to research and summarize, then visit a retailer’s website on their own. And that AI referral traffic, though small, converts 90% better than non-AI traffic.

Retailer-led agents build trust and deliver results

Even as AI shapes discovery, trust in AI-completed purchases remains low. According to Bain's Consumer Lab global survey, 55% of global shoppers using AI don’t fully trust it to complete a purchase.

However, retailer-led AI assistants deliver results and win trust. Consumers trust retailers’ own AI assistants (21%) nearly twice as much as third-party assistants (12%), finds Bain. The trust gap has narrowed as third-party agent adoption rises but still underscores that 1P visibility is crucial to a strong AI strategy.

Despite this, only 27 of the 100 largest US retailers have their own 1P assistant for customers. Retailers that rely solely on 3P assistants risk losing the primary customer relationship and the proprietary data that goes with it – which are hard to win back, Bain says.

A winning retailer’s year-end checklist

Bain’s report maps out a checklist for retailers to complete before the end of the holiday shopping season.

  • Run a prompt audit. Test your 3P visibility for the items and occasions your customers care about most, considering their intent and how they actually shop, before the final holiday rush.
  • Close generative engine optimization (GEO) gaps to ensure your value proposition comes through. Update your most important pages for the occasions you want to own and the promotions you want shoppers to see, using your customers’ language to describe you. In addition, start thinking about how personal agents, which prompt and behave differently from human customers, will change your strategy.
  • Check on your 1P assistant roadmap. If you don’t have a launch plan for early 2027, consider a white-label solution or an outsourced build to get there faster.
  • Get your most important data ready. Assess whether your consumer and product data is ready for hyper-personalization in your 1P assistant. If not, move quickly on the highest-value data first.
  • Determine your agent-to-agent strategy. Assign an owner and put pen to paper before the holidays. Take a stance on how open your 1P assistant will be to outside agents.

Media contacts:  

Mike Simon (New York) — mike.simon@bain.com

Gary Duncan (London) — gary.duncan@bain.com 

Ann Lee (Singapore) — ann.lee@bain.com 

About Bain & Company

Bain & Company works with leaders worldwide to solve their toughest challenges and deliver enduring results. Since 1973, we’ve partnered with clients, including private equity and portfolio companies, to build the capabilities they need to stay ahead of change and help them redefine their industries. We measure our success by our clients’ success, and we proudly hold the highest levels of client advocacy in our field.

Bain is consistently recognized globally as one of the best places to work. We operate as one global team, uniting strategists, industry and functional experts, technologists, and advisors with a vibrant ecosystem of technology partners.

Notes to Editors

Bain & Company was founded in 1973 and today has 19,000 employees across 67 cities in 40 countries. We have worked with more than two-thirds of the Global 500 and more than 9,000 companies worldwide. Bain has pledged to deliver $2 billion in pro bono consulting to nonprofit, public-sector and charitable organizations by 2035. The firm is consistently recognized as a Leader in major analyst rankings across multiple areas, including digital business, innovation, strategy, experience design, customer experience, and carbon-zero transformation.