Skip to Content
  • Offices

    Offices

    North & Latin America
    • Atlanta
    • Austin
    • Bogota
    • Boston
    • Buenos Aires
    • Chicago
    • Dallas
    • Denver
    • Houston
    • Los Angeles
    • Mexico City
    • Minneapolis
    • Monterrey
    • Montreal
    • New York
    • Rio de Janeiro
    • San Francisco
    • Santiago
    • São Paulo
    • Seattle
    • Silicon Valley
    • Toronto
    • Washington, DC
    Europe & Africa
    • Amsterdam
    • Athens
    • Berlin
    • Brussels
    • Copenhagen
    • Dusseldorf
    • Frankfurt
    • Helsinki
    • Istanbul
    • Johannesburg
    • Kyiv
    • Lisbon
    • London
    • Madrid
    • Milan
    • Munich
    • Oslo
    • Paris
    • Rome
    • Stockholm
    • Vienna
    • Warsaw
    • Zurich
    Middle East
    • Doha
    • Dubai
    • Riyadh
    Asia & Australia
    • Bangkok
    • Beijing
    • Bengaluru
    • Brisbane
    • Ho Chi Minh City
    • Hong Kong
    • Jakarta
    • Kuala Lumpur
    • Manila
    • Melbourne
    • Mumbai
    • New Delhi
    • Perth
    • Seoul
    • Shanghai
    • Singapore
    • Sydney
    • Tokyo
    See all offices
  • Alumni
  • Media Center
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Chile | Español

    Select your region and language

    Global
    • Global (English)
    North & Latin America
    • Brazil (Português)
    • Argentina (Español)
    • Canada (Français)
    • Chile (Español)
    • Colombia (Español)
    Europe, Middle East, & Africa
    • France (Français)
    • DACH Region (Deutsch)
    • Italy (Italiano)
    • Spain (Español)
    • Greece (Elliniká)
    Asia & Australia
    • China (中文版)
    • Korea (한국어)
    • Japan (日本語)
  • Saved items (0)
    Saved items (0)

    You have no saved items.

    Bookmark content that interests you and it will be saved here for you to read or share later.

    Explore Bain Insights
  • Industries
    Main menu

    Industries

    • Aeroespacial y Defensa
    • Agroindustria
    • Químicos
    • Construcción e Infraestructura
    • Productos de Consumo
    • Servicios Financieros
    • Salud y Ciencias de la Vida
    • Maquinaria y Equipo Industrial
    • Medios y Entretenimiento
      Industries
      Medios y Entretenimiento
      • Media Lab
    • Metales
    • Minería
    • Petróleo y Gas
    • Papel y Empaque
    • Private Equity
      Industries
      Private Equity
      • Due Diligence
      • Exit Planning
      • Firm Strategy & Operations
      • Portfolio Value Creation
    • Sector Público y Social
    • Retail
    • Tecnología
    • Telecomunicaciones
      Industries
      Telecomunicaciones
      • Capital Expenditure
      • Telco Digital Transformation
    • Transporte
    • Viajes y Turismo
    • Servicios Públicos y Energías Renovables
  • Consulting Services
    Main menu

    Consulting Services

    • Customer Experience
    • Sustainability
    • Innovation
    • M&A
    • Operations
    • People & Organization
    • Private Equity
    • Sales & Marketing
    • Strategy
    • AI, Insights, and Solutions
    • Technology
    • Transformation
  • Digital
  • Insights
    Main menu

    Insights

    • Industry Insights
    • Services Insights
    • Bain Books
    • Webinars
    • Bain Futures
    View all Insights
    Featured topics
    • Tariff Response
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Thriving in Uncertainty
    • Executive Conversations
    • Macro Trends
    • Private Equity Report
    • M&A Report
    • Healthcare Private Equity Report
    • Paper & Packaging Report
    • Technology Report
    • CEO Insights
    • CFO Insights
    • COO Insights
    • CIO Insights
    • CMO Insights
    View all featured topics
  • About
    Main menu

    About

    • What We Do
    • What We Believe
    • Our People & Leadership
    • Client Results
    • Awards & Recognition
    • Global Affiliations
    Further: Our global responsibility
    • Sustainability
    • Social Impact
    • World Economic Forum
    Learn more about Further
  • Carreras
    Main menu

    Carreras

    • Trabaja con Nosotros
      Carreras
      Trabaja con Nosotros
      • Find Your Place
      • Nuestras Áreas de Trabajo
      • Equipos Integrados
      • Estudiantes
      • Internships & Programs
      • Eventos de Reclutamiento
    • La Vida en Bain
      Carreras
      La Vida en Bain
      • Blog: Inside Bain
      • Historias Profesionales
      • Nuestra Gente
      • Dónde Trabajamos
      • Apoyando tu Crecimiento
      • Grupos de Afinidad
      • Beneficios
    • Impact Stories
    • Nuestro Proceso
      Carreras
      Nuestro Proceso
      • Qué Esperar
      • Entrevistas
    FIND JOBS
  • Offices
    Main menu

    Offices

    • North & Latin America
      Offices
      North & Latin America
      • Atlanta
      • Austin
      • Bogota
      • Boston
      • Buenos Aires
      • Chicago
      • Dallas
      • Denver
      • Houston
      • Los Angeles
      • Mexico City
      • Minneapolis
      • Monterrey
      • Montreal
      • New York
      • Rio de Janeiro
      • San Francisco
      • Santiago
      • São Paulo
      • Seattle
      • Silicon Valley
      • Toronto
      • Washington, DC
    • Europe & Africa
      Offices
      Europe & Africa
      • Amsterdam
      • Athens
      • Berlin
      • Brussels
      • Copenhagen
      • Dusseldorf
      • Frankfurt
      • Helsinki
      • Istanbul
      • Johannesburg
      • Kyiv
      • Lisbon
      • London
      • Madrid
      • Milan
      • Munich
      • Oslo
      • Paris
      • Rome
      • Stockholm
      • Vienna
      • Warsaw
      • Zurich
    • Middle East
      Offices
      Middle East
      • Doha
      • Dubai
      • Riyadh
    • Asia & Australia
      Offices
      Asia & Australia
      • Bangkok
      • Beijing
      • Bengaluru
      • Brisbane
      • Ho Chi Minh City
      • Hong Kong
      • Jakarta
      • Kuala Lumpur
      • Manila
      • Melbourne
      • Mumbai
      • New Delhi
      • Perth
      • Seoul
      • Shanghai
      • Singapore
      • Sydney
      • Tokyo
    See all offices
  • Alumni
  • Media Center
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Chile | Español
    Main menu

    Select your region and language

    • Global
      Select your region and language
      Global
      • Global (English)
    • North & Latin America
      Select your region and language
      North & Latin America
      • Brazil (Português)
      • Argentina (Español)
      • Canada (Français)
      • Chile (Español)
      • Colombia (Español)
    • Europe, Middle East, & Africa
      Select your region and language
      Europe, Middle East, & Africa
      • France (Français)
      • DACH Region (Deutsch)
      • Italy (Italiano)
      • Spain (Español)
      • Greece (Elliniká)
    • Asia & Australia
      Select your region and language
      Asia & Australia
      • China (中文版)
      • Korea (한국어)
      • Japan (日本語)
  • Saved items  (0)
    Main menu
    Saved items (0)

    You have no saved items.

    Bookmark content that interests you and it will be saved here for you to read or share later.

    Explore Bain Insights
  • Industries
    • Industries

      • Aeroespacial y Defensa
      • Agroindustria
      • Químicos
      • Construcción e Infraestructura
      • Productos de Consumo
      • Servicios Financieros
      • Salud y Ciencias de la Vida
      • Maquinaria y Equipo Industrial
      • Medios y Entretenimiento
      • Metales
      • Minería
      • Petróleo y Gas
      • Papel y Empaque
      • Private Equity
      • Sector Público y Social
      • Retail
      • Tecnología
      • Telecomunicaciones
      • Transporte
      • Viajes y Turismo
      • Servicios Públicos y Energías Renovables
  • Consulting Services
    • Consulting Services

      • Customer Experience
      • Sustainability
      • Innovation
      • M&A
      • Operations
      • People & Organization
      • Private Equity
      • Sales & Marketing
      • Strategy
      • AI, Insights, and Solutions
      • Technology
      • Transformation
  • Digital
  • Insights
    • Insights

      • Industry Insights
      • Services Insights
      • Bain Books
      • Webinars
      • Bain Futures
      View all Insights
      Featured topics
      • Tariff Response
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Thriving in Uncertainty
      • Executive Conversations
      • Macro Trends
      • Private Equity Report
      • M&A Report
      • Healthcare Private Equity Report
      • Paper & Packaging Report
      • Technology Report
      • CEO Insights
      • CFO Insights
      • COO Insights
      • CIO Insights
      • CMO Insights
      View all featured topics
  • About
    • About

      • What We Do
      • What We Believe
      • Our People & Leadership
      • Client Results
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Global Affiliations
      Further: Our global responsibility
      • Sustainability
      • Social Impact
      • World Economic Forum
      Learn more about Further
  • Carreras
    Popular Searches
    • Agile
    • Digital
    • Strategy
    Your Previous Searches
      Recently Visited Pages

      Content added to saved items

      Saved items (0)

      Removed from saved items

      Saved items (0)

      Brief

      Trouble in Store

      Trouble in Store

      A receding tide exposes the problems in China’s retail distribution system.

      By James Root and Weiwei Xing

      • min read
      }

      Brief

      Trouble in Store
      en

      It’s no secret that the past few years have been a rude awakening for consumer goods companies in China. After riding a massive wave of surging consumer demand for two decades, companies in fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG)—from beer and cigarettes to diapers and dish soap—find themselves scrounging for growth. Growth in China’s FMCG market, which we estimate at about $900 billion per year based on Euromonitor data, plummeted from nearly 12% in 2012 to about 3.5% in 2015, according to the Bain-Kantar China Shopper Report. The sharp drop is a result of China’s slowing economy and shifting consumer behavior. It’s a two-speed China today, with some categories continuing to prosper while others, such as instant noodles, are getting whacked with sales declines of more than 5%, according to market researcher Kantar Worldpanel.

      Lurking below the surface is another huge challenge to the performance of consumer goods manufacturers: China’s antiquated, fragmented distribution system. It’s costly, inefficient, and provides only a hazy line of sight to the consumer. Instead of acting as a partner that can help manufacturers pull sales through retail channels when demand falters, the distribution system in China compounds the problems of slower growth. Without a major transformation of the distribution system, both global and local Chinese consumer product companies could be facing years of struggle to reaccelerate growth.

      Nobody gave much thought to the distribution system when the economy was booming and consumer brands scrambled to keep up with demand. Indeed, the fact that the system could expeditiously deliver merchandise to millions of stores across an enormous land mass and grow spontaneously to accommodate rising demand was something of a logistics miracle. But manufacturers also knew that eventually they would need a modern distribution system that could help them drive sales.

      The critical flaw in the current system—and a growing business problem for manufacturers—is the way it connects manufacturers to what Nielsen estimates to be more than 3 million traditional stores that dot the Chinese landscape. We estimate that these tiny shops in urban neighborhoods and rural areas still account for at least 40% of FMCG sales in China. To move an item, say a can of tomato paste, from a plant near Shanghai to a corner grocery in rural Gansu Province might require several handoffs. The first is to the primary distributor, who takes goods from the factory and passes them to sub-distributors or regional wholesalers, who in turn often rely on one or more layers of sub-distributors. From there, the tomato paste would go to any of the more than 10,000 local wholesalers that deliver goods to traditional stores.

      Now, the day of reckoning has arrived. The receding tide—sales were flat or down in half of FMCG categories from 2014 to 2015—has exposed the bleak economics and dysfunction of the distribution system. At each step, somebody takes a markup on the tomato paste, from about 0.5% for the primary distributor to 10% for the local wholesaler (see Figure 1). By the time the can reaches the shelf in Gansu, we estimate that the markup is easily 15% to 20%. Because of all these layers, when it comes to the millions of traditional shops that handle more than $350 billion in sales every year, manufacturers are flying blind.


      trouble-in-store-fig-01_embed

      This distribution system is now showing signs of stress. Many of the primary distributors that manufacturers rely on are poorly capitalized and lack capabilities beyond order taking and basic logistics. In the past, manufacturers simply added more of these distributors to grow sales: Most brands have hundreds of primary distributors. As sales slowed in recent years, manufacturers pushed more goods to these distributors, who turned around and jammed the channels below them, leaving a vast but unknown quantity of merchandise stranded. With thin margins and no capital cushion, some subscale distributors have already exited the business (see Figure 2). There is also constant churn among the sub-distributors and regional wholesalers that move product into smaller cities and rural areas. For one company in the beverage sector, distributor churn exceeded 15% in one of its largest regions last year; a company in packaged food had over 30% churn among its national distributors during a year of significant sales declines.


      trouble-in-store-fig-02_embed

      The woes of China’s distributors are approaching crisis proportions just when brands need them most. Today, only distributors can move products cost effectively to the smaller cities and rural areas where the best growth opportunities are found. Until 2015, when growth moderated, retail sales in Tier-3, Tier-4 and Tier-5 cities were rising by 8% a year, about four times the rate in Tier-1 and Tier-2 cities, according to the Bain-Kantar China Shopper Report. The report shows that even as modern formats such as hypermarkets lose momentum—hypermarket traffic dropped by 4.6% in 2015—growth continues in smaller modern-format grocery and convenience stores, which also rely on distributors.

      All this suggests a long period of rebuilding for China’s retail distribution system. At the end of the process, many of today’s primary distributors will not be around. Those that survive will have invested in the capabilities that brand owners value most: efficient distribution of the product and support in sell-through. At the same time, new digital business platforms are taking root to address the inefficiencies of the current “many brands to many stores” route-to-market (RTM) system. We count at least 50 such e-RTM businesses today, and they could help China leapfrog to a retail distribution system that is more efficient than what we see in some advanced economies. These platforms, however, are stuck in a catch-22: Operators need enough traditional trade outlets to join their platforms so that brand owners will be willing to abandon the old model while retailers want to see enough brands on a platform before they switch from distributors they have used for decades.

      James Root, a partner in the Consumer Products practice, discusses the challenges that brand owners and retailers now face, as well as the emerging digital platforms that could supplant distributors.

      These new platforms promise enormous potential prizes for both retailers and brand owners. Traditional store owners could vastly simplify their lives with one-stop shopping, rather than dealing with dozens of distributors or wholesalers. Brand owners could reduce their RTM costs and improve access to hard-to-reach outlets while gaining perfect visibility of their product during its distribution journey. For distributors and wholesalers, however, the outlook is not encouraging. The $100 billion of markup that Bain estimates flows to them every year in the current model would come under threat. Worse, in some emerging e-RTM models, there is little role for the distributors at all.

      This is all in the future. For the time being, FMCG manufacturers cannot count on distributors of any kind to help them win in a much more challenging Chinese consumer market.

      James Root is a partner in Bain & Company’s Hong Kong office and leader of the firm’s Asia-Pacific Organization practice. Weiwei Xing is a Bain manager also based in Hong Kong.


      trouble-in-store-fig-01_full

      trouble-in-store-fig-02_full
      Authors
      • Headshot of James Root
        James Root
        Partner, Hong Kong
      • Headshot of Weiwei Xing
        Weiwei Xing
        Alumni, Hong Kong
      Related Industries
      • Consumer Products
      Related Consulting Services
      • People and Organization
      Consumer Products
      The Hottest Brand in China Is Australia

      How can Australian consumer goods companies profit from China’s hunger for natural, safe and healthy products?

      Read more
      Consumer Products
      Dealing with Two-Speed China

      How China's fast-moving consumer goods market is effectively operating on two speeds across multiple dimensions.

      Read more
      Consumer Products
      Can Southeast Asia Live Up to Its E-commerce Potential?

      With a huge and digitally sophisticated population, Southeast Asia is on the verge of becoming a haven for e-commerce. Winning starts by understanding how consumer behavior here is quickly evolving.

      Read more
      Consumer Products
      Shift to Vertical: David Haines, Group CEO, Flora Food Group

      What does it take to stay connected to your customers when scale and complexity threaten to pull you away? 

      Read more
      Consumer Products
      US Consumer Health Update

      Consumers at every income level entered the year on weaker footing, with the downside risks continuing to grow.

      Read more
      First published in noviembre 2016
      Tags
      • Consumer Products
      • People and Organization

      How We've Helped Clients

      A Food Company’s Bold Play to Restore Margin and Growth

      See more related case studies

      A Consumer Products Giant Accelerates Its Sustainability Agenda

      See more related case studies

      Designing a Sales Compensation Plan Based on an Unusual Metric

      See more related case studies

      Want to continue the conversation

      We help global leaders with their organization's most critical issues and opportunities. Together, we create enduring change and results

      Bain Insights. Our perspectives on critical issues global businesses face in today's challenging environment, delivered monthly.

      *I have read and understand Bain’s Privacy Notice.

      Please read and agree to the Privacy Policy.
      Bain & Company
      Contact us Sustainability Accessibility Terms of use Privacy Modern Slavery Act Statement Cookie Policy Sitemap Log In

      © 1996-2026 Bain & Company, Inc.

      Contact Bain

      How can we help you?

      • Business inquiry
      • Career information
      • Press relations
      • Partnership request
      • Speaker request
      See all offices