Skip to Content
  • 오피스

    오피스

    미주
    • Atlanta
    • Austin
    • Bogota
    • Boston
    • Buenos Aires
    • Chicago
    • Dallas
    • Denver
    • Houston
    • Los Angeles
    • Mexico City
    • Minneapolis
    • Monterrey
    • Montreal
    • New York
    • Rio de Janeiro
    • San Francisco
    • Santiago
    • São Paulo
    • Seattle
    • Silicon Valley
    • Toronto
    • Washington, DC
    유럽, 중동, 아프리카
    • Amsterdam
    • Athens
    • Berlin
    • Brussels
    • Copenhagen
    • Doha
    • Dubai
    • Dusseldorf
    • Frankfurt
    • Helsinki
    • Istanbul
    • Johannesburg
    • Kyiv
    • Lisbon
    • London
    • Madrid
    • Milan
    • Munich
    • Oslo
    • Paris
    • Riyadh
    • Rome
    • Stockholm
    • Vienna
    • Warsaw
    • Zurich
    아시아, 호주
    • Bangkok
    • Beijing
    • Bengaluru
    • Brisbane
    • Ho Chi Minh City
    • Hong Kong
    • Jakarta
    • Kuala Lumpur
    • Manila
    • Melbourne
    • Mumbai
    • New Delhi
    • Perth
    • Seoul
    • Shanghai
    • Singapore
    • Sydney
    • Tokyo
    오피스 전체보기
  • 얼럼나이
  • 미디어 센터
  • 구독
  • 연락처
  • Korea | 한국어

    지역 및 언어 선택

    글로벌
    • Global (English)
    미주
    • Brazil (Português)
    • Argentina (Español)
    • Canada (Français)
    • Chile (Español)
    • Colombia (Español)
    유럽, 중동, 아프리카
    • France (Français)
    • DACH Region (Deutsch)
    • Italy (Italiano)
    • Spain (Español)
    • Greece (Elliniká)
    아시아, 호주
    • China (中文版)
    • Korea (한국어)
    • Japan (日本語)
  • Saved items (0)
    Saved items (0)

    You have no saved items.

    관심 있는 내용을 북마크하여 Red 폴더에 저장할 수 있습니다. Red 폴더 에서 저장된 내용을 읽거나 공유해보세요.

    Explore Bain Insights
  • 산업
    메인 메뉴

    산업

    • 우주항공, 방산 및 정부 서비스
    • 농업 관련 산업
    • 화학
    • 인프라, 건설 및 건축 자재
    • 소비재
    • 금융 서비스
    • 헬스케어
    • 산업용 기계 및 장비
    • 미디어 및 엔터테인먼트
    • 금속
    • 광업
    • 석유 및 가스
    • 제지 및 패키징 산업
    • 사모펀드
    • 사회 및 공공 부문
    • 유통
    • 기술
    • 텔레콤
    • 운송
    • 여행·여가
    • 유틸리티 및 재생가능 에너지
  • 컨설팅 서비스
    메인 메뉴

    컨설팅 서비스

    • Customer Experience
    • ESG
    • Innovation
    • M&A
    • 운영
    • 조직
    • 사모펀드
    • 고객 전략 및 마케팅
    • 전략
    • AI, 인사이트 및 솔루션
    • Technology
    • 변화 혁신
  • Digital
  • 인사이트
  • 베인 소개
    메인 메뉴

    베인 소개

    • 업무 소개
    • 베인의 신념
    • 구성원 및 리더십 소개
    • 고객 성과
    • 주요 수상 경력
    • 글로벌 파트너사
    Further: Our global responsibility
    • 다양성과 포용
    • 사회 공헌 활동
    • Sustainability
    • World Economic Forum
    Learn more about Further
  • Careers
    메인 메뉴

    Careers

    • Work with Us
      Careers
      Work with Us
      • Find Your Place
      • Our Work Areas
      • Integrated Teams
      • Students
      • Internships & Programs
      • Recruiting Events
    • Life at Bain
      Careers
      Life at Bain
      • Blog: Inside Bain
      • Career Stories
      • Our People
      • Where We Work
      • Supporting Your Growth
      • Affinity Groups
      • Benefits
    • Impact Stories
    • Hiring Process
      Careers
      Hiring Process
      • What to Expect
      • Interviewing
    FIND JOBS
  • 오피스
    메인 메뉴

    오피스

    • 미주
      오피스
      미주
      • Atlanta
      • Austin
      • Bogota
      • Boston
      • Buenos Aires
      • Chicago
      • Dallas
      • Denver
      • Houston
      • Los Angeles
      • Mexico City
      • Minneapolis
      • Monterrey
      • Montreal
      • New York
      • Rio de Janeiro
      • San Francisco
      • Santiago
      • São Paulo
      • Seattle
      • Silicon Valley
      • Toronto
      • Washington, DC
    • 유럽, 중동, 아프리카
      오피스
      유럽, 중동, 아프리카
      • Amsterdam
      • Athens
      • Berlin
      • Brussels
      • Copenhagen
      • Doha
      • Dubai
      • Dusseldorf
      • Frankfurt
      • Helsinki
      • Istanbul
      • Johannesburg
      • Kyiv
      • Lisbon
      • London
      • Madrid
      • Milan
      • Munich
      • Oslo
      • Paris
      • Riyadh
      • Rome
      • Stockholm
      • Vienna
      • Warsaw
      • Zurich
    • 아시아, 호주
      오피스
      아시아, 호주
      • Bangkok
      • Beijing
      • Bengaluru
      • Brisbane
      • Ho Chi Minh City
      • Hong Kong
      • Jakarta
      • Kuala Lumpur
      • Manila
      • Melbourne
      • Mumbai
      • New Delhi
      • Perth
      • Seoul
      • Shanghai
      • Singapore
      • Sydney
      • Tokyo
    오피스 전체보기
  • 얼럼나이
  • 미디어 센터
  • 구독
  • 연락처
  • Korea | 한국어
    메인 메뉴

    지역 및 언어 선택

    • 글로벌
      지역 및 언어 선택
      글로벌
      • Global (English)
    • 미주
      지역 및 언어 선택
      미주
      • Brazil (Português)
      • Argentina (Español)
      • Canada (Français)
      • Chile (Español)
      • Colombia (Español)
    • 유럽, 중동, 아프리카
      지역 및 언어 선택
      유럽, 중동, 아프리카
      • France (Français)
      • DACH Region (Deutsch)
      • Italy (Italiano)
      • Spain (Español)
      • Greece (Elliniká)
    • 아시아, 호주
      지역 및 언어 선택
      아시아, 호주
      • China (中文版)
      • Korea (한국어)
      • Japan (日本語)
  • Saved items  (0)
    메인 메뉴
    Saved items (0)

    You have no saved items.

    관심 있는 내용을 북마크하여 Red 폴더에 저장할 수 있습니다. Red 폴더 에서 저장된 내용을 읽거나 공유해보세요.

    Explore Bain Insights
  • 산업
    • 산업

      • 우주항공, 방산 및 정부 서비스
      • 농업 관련 산업
      • 화학
      • 인프라, 건설 및 건축 자재
      • 소비재
      • 금융 서비스
      • 헬스케어
      • 산업용 기계 및 장비
      • 미디어 및 엔터테인먼트
      • 금속
      • 광업
      • 석유 및 가스
      • 제지 및 패키징 산업
      • 사모펀드
      • 사회 및 공공 부문
      • 유통
      • 기술
      • 텔레콤
      • 운송
      • 여행·여가
      • 유틸리티 및 재생가능 에너지
  • 컨설팅 서비스
    • 컨설팅 서비스

      • Customer Experience
      • ESG
      • Innovation
      • M&A
      • 운영
      • 조직
      • 사모펀드
      • 고객 전략 및 마케팅
      • 전략
      • AI, 인사이트 및 솔루션
      • Technology
      • 변화 혁신
  • Digital
  • 인사이트
  • 베인 소개
    • 베인 소개

      • 업무 소개
      • 베인의 신념
      • 구성원 및 리더십 소개
      • 고객 성과
      • 주요 수상 경력
      • 글로벌 파트너사
      Further: Our global responsibility
      • 다양성과 포용
      • 사회 공헌 활동
      • Sustainability
      • World Economic Forum
      Learn more about Further
  • Careers
    최근 검색어
      최근 방문 페이지

      Content added to saved items

      Saved items (0)

      Removed from saved items

      Saved items (0)

      HBR.org

      Online shopping isn't as profitable as you think

      Online shopping isn't as profitable as you think

      Retailers who fuse the best of digital and physical technologies can capitalize on digital advantages both online and in stores.

      글 Darrell Rigby

      • 읽기 소요시간

      Article

      Online shopping isn't as profitable as you think
      en

      This article originally appeared on HBR.org.

      When I argue that e-commerce isn’t likely to destroy innovative omnichannel retailers, I typically receive Comments. Am I really suggesting that the growth of e-commerce will slow before it annihilates most physical retailing? And how could I possibly argue that the economics of omnichannel retailers are as favorable as those of pure-play e-tailers?

      Growth rates first. Several organizations track e-commerce sales, including the U.S. Census Bureau, ComScore, eMarketer, and Forrester. All show similar trends. For example, Forrester’s data on the top 30 product categories (which account for 97% of total e-commerce sales) indicates that e-commerce growth fluctuates with economic conditions but is clearly slowing overall (see figure on HBR.org).

      This is a familiar growth pattern: E-commerce as a percentage of total retail sales seems to be following a classic S-shaped logistic curve. If historical trends continue, e-commerce’s share of retail will rise from 11% today to about 18% in 2030, albeit with big variations by category.

      Of course, that pesky “if historical trends continue” phrase generates ferocious debates. What if e-commerce creates such enormous economic advantages that physical retailers simply can’t compete?

      E-commerce companies, like physical retailers, have wide-ranging cost structures and financial results. In general, however, e-commerce operations aren’t as cheap to run as most people think. Their economics greatly resemble those of mail order catalogs—in fact, many e-commerce businesses continue to use catalogs in their marketing mix—and they aren’t all favorable. Amazon, whose results are similar to those of other e-commerce companies and divisions, has averaged only 1.3% in operating margins over the past three years. Operating margins for department, discount and specialty stores typically run 6% to 10%. Lower margins can come only from lower prices or higher costs.

      “Ah,” you might say, “Amazon does have lower prices, and its costs are higher only because it is investing so heavily in growth.” But how much of the difference do these reasons explain?

      Price comparisons are always tricky: they are complicated by the basket of items selected, how promotions and coupons are treated, the handling of loyalty program rebates, and many other variables. But Amazon’s prices aren’t uniformly lower than competitors’. One recent Kantar Retail study of 59 items found that prices at Walmart’s Supercenter stores were 16% below Amazon’s. Another study, by William Blair & Company, found that prices at several physical retailers are about 10% below Amazon’s on items costing less than $25. In cases where store-based retailers do charge higher prices, several I have spoken with calculate that closing price gaps with Amazon would cost them between 1 and 3 percentage points of operating margin. That would still leave them with 2 to 8 points of margin advantage.

      But what about the economics of e-commerce orders? Even there, creative omnichannel retailers aren’t necessarily at a disadvantage. E-commerce companies ship to customers from large, expensive, highly productive fulfillment centers. (A state-of-the-art center can cost $250 million or more to build, or about 10 times as much as a big box store.) Fewer fulfillment centers mean lower capital expenses but higher shipping costs and slower deliveries. Meanwhile, omnichannel retailers already have hundreds or thousands of distribution centers called “stores.” It costs only about a dollar more to pick an order from store shelves than from automated warehouses, and the proximity to customers saves at least as much in shipping costs—especially for in-store pickups, rapid deliveries, and returns.

      It’s true that rapidly growing e-commerce companies like Amazon have been investing heavily in their future. Still, market maturation often forces sustained expenditures just to hold ground. For example, as Amazon builds fulfillment centers in more states, those states are now forcing it to collect sales taxes—an effective price increase of about 7% on average—and researchers at Ohio State University say that reduces spending on Amazon by about 10%. Substantial investments in price or differentiation may be required to offset such effects. Several public e-commerce companies are already experiencing reduced growth and margins as competition intensifies.

      A common argument is that rapidly evolving digital technologies will increase e-commerce’s advantages. But retailers who fuse the best of digital and physical technologies—we examined these “digical” innovations in an article in the September issue of HBR—can capitalize on digital advantages both online and in stores. Digital technologies will improve in-store visual merchandising, help customers choose the type of service they prefer, speed checkout times, customize offers, and provide virtual connections to global experts or trusted friends. Radio frequency identification (RFID) tags will improve in-store fulfillment speeds. Automated backrooms in supermarkets will pick and pack commodities while customers hand-select their favorite produce and meats.

      I’m not underestimating the magnitude of the changes physical retailers must implement. But digical strategies combining the best of both worlds will be more attractive to a broader range of customers while enabling superior economics. Perhaps this is why even Jeff Bezos has said that if Amazon can find the right idea, “We would love to open physical stores.”

      Innovation expert Darrell Rigby is a Bain partner and author of Winning in Turbulence.

      저자
      • Headshot of Darrell Rigby
        Darrell Rigby
        파트너, Boston
      문의하기
      관련 컨설팅 서비스
      • 전략
      유통
      E-commerce is not eating retail

      Omnichannel retailers are likely to enjoy significant advantages over retailers that fail to integrate digital and physical channels.

      자세히 보기
      유통
      Leading a Digical® Transformation

      The big change taking place in business today is the combination of digital and physical elements to create wholly new sources of value.

      자세히 보기
      전략
      Six Threats Demand a New Playbook for Banks in Wealth and Asset Management

      AI, direct-to-consumer models, and the return of local priorities are redrawing industry lines.

      자세히 보기
      전략
      Compete, Evolve, Compete Again

      What does it really take to stay relevant when the world refuses to stand still?

      자세히 보기
      전략
      The Magic of Founder-led Companies

      Companies with their founder present performed twice as well as their peers in the S&P 500 over the past decade.

      자세히 보기
      First published in 8월 2014
      태그
      • 전략

      프로젝트 사례

      전략 Jump-starting innovation for a telecom solutions provider

      See more related case studies

      전략 New products propel profitability for metals manufacturer

      See more related case studies

      전략 An auctioneer makes a winning online bid

      See more related case studies

      베인에 궁금하신 점이 있으신가요?

      베인은 주저 없이 변화를 마주할 줄 아는 용감한 리더들과 함께합니다. 그리고, 이들의 담대한 용기는 고객사의 성공으로 이어집니다.

      Selected for you

      Global Private Equity Report 2026

      Powering forward in a new era: Our annual report examines key trends shaping the dealmaking landscape.

      For you

      급변하는 비즈니스 환경에서 살아남기 위한 선도자의 시각. 월간 Bain Insights에서 글로벌 비즈니스의 핵심 이슈를 확인하십시오.

      *개인정보 정책을 읽었으며 그 내용에 동의합니다.

      Privacy Policy를 읽고 동의해주십시오.
      Bain & Company
      문의하기 환경정책 Accessibility 이용약관 개인정보 보호 쿠키 사용 정책 Sitemap Log In

      © 1996-2026 Bain & Company, Inc.

      문의하기

      무엇을 도와드릴까요?

      • 프로젝트 문의
      • 채용 정보
      • 언론
      • 제휴 문의
      • 연사 초청
      오피스 전체보기