The Visionary CEO’s Guide to Sustainability
To thrive long term in a world in which humans annually consume 1.75 times the natural resources the earth can regenerate in 12 months, businesses must decouple growth from resource extraction. In addition to improving environmental sustainability, circularity offers companies in most industries a way to gain competitive advantage at significant scale and thrive in a future in which profits will be made differently.
Circular practices like recovering resources, extending the life of products, and promoting a sharing economy offer valuable benefits, including greater business resilience, more efficient use of resources, and revenue growth from new customers, services, and innovation. Many business leaders recognize this. In a survey conducted by Bain & Company and the World Economic Forum in October 2022, 35% of executives ranked circularity as one of their organization’s highest priorities, the third highest tally after “optimize supply chain performance” and “operate sustainably.” And in a Bain survey, executives reported that they anticipate 30% growth in share of revenue from circularity between 2021 and 2030.
Even so, most organizations operate today with a business model built for a linear world. These models won’t thrive in a circular economy. To unlock circularity’s true value, executives must transform two things: their material model—how they source and use resources—and their business model—how they generate revenue and profits (see Figure 1).
To build sustainability and long-term economic value, companies must simultaneously redesign the way they use materials and how they construct their business model
Insurgents like Back Market, a refurbished device marketplace, and the luxury reseller The RealReal are already doing that—disrupting industries with new ways of operating and earning revenue. Bain research has found that 45% of executives expect these types of new entrants to change their industry, and concern about the threat from insurgents is highest among those incumbent companies that have done the most planning for the circular transition.
Incumbents are acting, too. Of 380 large global companies studied in 10 different industries, 55% have made specific, measurable circularity commitments, according to Bain research. These often focus on recycled inputs and waste reduction. Few have begun to really rethink their full business model, however, and that’s where much of circularity’s potential payoff often lies.
Companies can begin to comprehensively build for a circular world by taking two important steps:
1. Define the circular ambition.
From today’s linear ways of operating, circularity looks very costly. And the value it will add is often underestimated. To overcome that, companies must envision what the future will look like: where money will be spent, how profits will be earned, and which types of companies will earn them. This includes imagining how circular transformations will reshape interaction with customers, suppliers, and the broader ecosystem, and also how circularity models can help tackle pressing operating issues like scarce and diminishing resources, supply chain disruptions, regulation, and increasing environmental damage.
For most companies, this transition is likely to evolve over the next decade, or potentially longer. Consider a trucking company that is in the midst of a multiyear redesign of its business for a profitable circular future. Triggered by three things—the technology breakthroughs that have fueled the growth of low-emitting electric and autonomous vehicles, usage-based business models, and the fight for recycled and scarce inputs—the company is planning for the possibility that, in the future, customers will buy access to trucking based on usage rather than owning their own trucks.
At the same time, the company is incorporating circularity into how it competes in today’s marketplace, designing its trucks and components to be more modular and upgradable, and thereby longer lived. This also makes components easier to recover at the end of a vehicle’s useful life for use in remanufacturing. Because reuse extends component lifetime, it is one way to reduce Scope 3 emissions. Supporting sustainable, circular, cost-competitive inputs and boosting uptime also reduces emissions. And all these efforts reduce total operating expenses.
In this way, thinking about its circular ambition is helping this trucking company position itself to defend its business and navigate potential regulatory changes.
2. Plan future profits.
As new business models change how companies earn revenue and the more efficient use of resources reduces costs, the way profits are made will evolve as well.
That’s why it’s important for every company to understand: 1) where and how it can make money in a circular world, 2) the stages at which its industry and market are likely to reach a level of adoption and maturity that justifies investment in that model, and 3) how that future should influence new products and services being created today.
Innovative technology, evolving regulations, consumer and customer demand, supply chain volatility, and material scarcity are among the factors that will influence those answers. They won’t always be perfectly predictable, and executives may not know all the answers, but they can and should identify the signposts they need to watch out for, the signals that can indicate an acceleration in the shift to circularity, such as declining unit production costs or the development of supporting infrastructure.
Consider how the increasing scarcity of materials like lithium and rare earth metals needed for electric vehicle (EV) batteries will shift a portion of car industry profits toward companies collecting, sorting, and recycling EV batteries. While it’s hard to predict exactly how this will play out, manufacturers with access to end-of-life batteries and recycling capabilities will have a strong strategic advantage in the future.
To understand where companies can make money, it’s critical to understand how market structures will transition in the future and which segments of the value chain will have a disproportionate degree of influence on critical flows of needed resources. Recognizing that the level of influence and control in its industry will shift toward those participants who facilitate the reverse flow of used materials and products, a chemical company is developing a plastics recycling strategy to commercialize recycled materials and gain access to scarce feedstock of postconsumer packaging, including PET and recycled aluminum. This will be a key strategic advantage in the future when these materials become even more scarce.
Once critical market transitions are identified, companies must develop strategies to access, shift, and influence them, both alone and through an ecosystem of partners and other participants.
Actions to take now
CEOs planning for a more efficient, resilient, and profitable circular future benefit from taking certain actions now:
- Identify strategic opportunities for which circularity can create and accelerate value: new customers, new sources of revenue and monetization models, supply chain resilience, sustainability, and access to scarce supply, among others.
- Determine how circularity is likely to evolve in your industry (adoption curves), the signals or signposts to watch for signs of increased momentum in customer adoption, and how production cost will come down over time (experience curves).
- Define the material and business models that will help position the company for maximum competitive advantage.
- Anticipate transitioning of market structures and resulting distribution of influence and control across the value chain and invest to influence and secure the flow of critical resources.
- Map out and start building the broader ecosystem partnerships required to scale your circular solutions.
The authors would like to warmly thank Simone Doms, a practice director in Bain’s Sustainability & Responsibility practice in Munich, for her extensive contributions to this article.