Jakarta Post

Traditional Advertising Still Needed

Bain research shows that traditional media is more effective than digital in getting consumers to recall advertisements.

Von Kenji Govaers and Nader Elkhweet

First published on Juni 10, 2017
Min. Lesezeit


This article originally appeared on The Jakarta Post (subscription required). Even the most data-driven company is working blindly when it comes to understanding what it gets from spending on digital advertising. Digital media is great for reaching a specific set of consumers with targeted messages quickly, efficiently and at a lower cost. But new Bain & Company research has determined that it is far less effective than traditional media in getting consumers to recall, that is, bring back to mind, an advertisement for a well-established fast-moving consumer goods product and may not be enough to increase their interest in purchasing the product. These findings emerged from research conducted for a major consumer goods company in a developed market, and are important for companies struggling to calculate their returns when determining the right mix of digital and traditional advertising investments. We compared four types of media—online banner ads, online video, TV as well as storefronts—analyzing the cost for each additional 1 percent increase in reach and the rate at which viewers recalled the ads. As expected, digital media is less expensive for reaching a limited group of consumers. However, the "recollected reach"—the percentage of total population reached who recall a campaign—is lowest for digital media (online banners and videos), hitting a ceiling at around 30 percent. Read more at The Jakarta Post. Kenji Govaers is a Bain & Company partner based in Tokyo. Nader Elkhweet is a partner who leads Bain's Consumer Products and Retail practices in Jakarta.

This article originally appeared on The Jakarta Post (subscription required).

Even the most data-driven company is working blindly when it comes to understanding what it gets from spending on digital advertising.

Digital media is great for reaching a specific set of consumers with targeted messages quickly, efficiently and at a lower cost. But new Bain & Company research has determined that it is far less effective than traditional media in getting consumers to recall, that is, bring back to mind, an advertisement for a well-established fast-moving consumer goods product and may not be enough to increase their interest in purchasing the product.

These findings emerged from research conducted for a major consumer goods company in a developed market, and are important for companies struggling to calculate their returns when determining the right mix of digital and traditional advertising investments.

We compared four types of media—online banner ads, online video, TV as well as storefronts—analyzing the cost for each additional 1 percent increase in reach and the rate at which viewers recalled the ads. As expected, digital media is less expensive for reaching a limited group of consumers.

However, the "recollected reach"—the percentage of total population reached who recall a campaign—is lowest for digital media (online banners and videos), hitting a ceiling at around 30 percent.

Read more at The Jakarta Post.

Kenji Govaers is a Bain & Company partner based in Tokyo. Nader Elkhweet is a partner who leads Bain's Consumer Products and Retail practices in Jakarta.